Blood XX, Skin XY, High school

Chromosomes are tiny threads inside your cells that carry genes. A one-year-old boy’s blood test shows two X chromosomes (XX), a pattern doctors usually see in girls.
Could a test on another part of the boy’s body give a different answer than the blood test?
A boy whose blood came back female and his skin came back male
Doctors tested a baby boy and found XX chromosomes in his blood cells and XY in his skin cells. His blood came from one egg’s half set of chromosomes, copied twice, while his skin had DNA from both parents. Scientists call this a parthenogenetic chimera.

Your word of the day is
par-theh-no-jeh-NET-ik ky-MEER-uh
A body made of two cell lines, where one line grew from an egg with no DNA from a father. Also spelled chimera.

The boy’s blood cells carried one half-set of chromosomes from his mom, copied twice. His skin cells carried one half-set from each parent.
Which of the boy’s two cell lines has more genetic variety, and why?

A blood test read the boy as XX. A skin test read him as XY.
How can the boy’s blood test read XX while his skin test reads XY?

The boy’s body held an XX cell line and an XY cell line.
Why did the boy’s blood test miss his XY cells?
Most boys with XX cells carry a small piece of the Y chromosome on one X. That piece almost always comes from the father’s sperm.
Which result from the boy’s blood rules out a hidden Y piece, and how?
A hidden Y piece on one X would leave every cell in the boy’s body XX.
Which result from the boy’s skin rules out a hidden Y piece, and how?
As of 2021, scientists had reported six people with a mom-only cell line, carrying DNA from the mother alone. Genetic tests usually start with blood, yet in one of the six cases, none of the white blood cells tested came from the mom-only line.
How could a mom-only cell line go unnoticed?
A mom-only cell line carries DNA from the mother alone.
Which test would find more people with a mom-only cell line?
Claim, evidence, reasoning
More than 98 out of 100 of the boy’s blood cells came from the mom-only line, the cells with DNA from his mom alone. Fewer than 5 out of 100 of his skin cells did.
Which claim best explains how the boy’s body grew from one egg, with mom-only cells in most of his blood but few of his skin cells?

Claim, evidence, reasoning
Which evidence best backs the claim that one egg split early into a mom-only line and a two-parent line?

Claim, evidence, reasoning
Which reasoning best links the boy’s marker results to an early split in one egg?

Mouse embryos made from the mother’s DNA alone don’t survive past early development. Some genes switch on only in the copy that came from the father. Yet some mice with a mix of mom-only cells and two-parent cells survive.
Which question would best help explain why the boy’s two-parent cells were important?

Which evidence would show which of the boy’s tissues need genes that switch on only in dad’s copy?

Scientists think the boy’s body grew from one egg, yet his blood and skin carried different DNA.
Starting from one egg, how could mitosis and differentiation give the boy mom-only blood cells and two-parent skin cells?

Lesson complete
Today’s word
parthenogenetic chimaera
par-theh-no-jeh-NET-ik ky-MEER-uh
A body made of two cell lines, where one line grew from an egg with no DNA from a father. Also spelled chimera.
Look at these again
You got every question right the first time.
Sources
- Strain and others, Nature Genetics, 1995 (free abstract)
- Yamazawa and others, Journal of Medical Genetics, 2010
- Masunaga and others, Clinical Epigenetics, 2021
- “Scientists: Boy came from egg that didn’t wait for sperm,” Tampa Bay Times, September 30, 1995
- MedlinePlus Genetics: 46,XX testicular difference of sex development, Klinefelter syndrome, Turner syndrome, genomic imprinting and uniparental disomy
- Vision and Change core concepts and competencies, as summarized in Brownell and others, CBE Life Sciences Education, 2014
- Word origins from Dictionary.com: chimera, chimaera, chimerical, genetic, chromosome, chromo-, chromatic, -some, ribosome
- Mark Cartwright, “Chimera of Arezzo,” World History Encyclopedia
- Spanish and French meanings from Wiktionary: quimera, chimère